Skip to content

How to Find the Best MCAT Tutor: Qualifications To Look For

Updated 6 min read3 sections

In this article3

So, you’ve decided to pursue personalized tutoring to prepare for the MCAT exam. You’re scrolling through all the ads online and find student after student offering to coach you to the perfect 528. How do you know which one is the right tutor for you? And how do you know that what they’re promising you is real?

Let’s break down how to find the best MCAT tutor that will help you succeed in your goals and work with you to build a realistic study schedule.

What Qualifications Should an MCAT Tutor Have?

What MCAT Score Should My Tutor Have?

Most MCAT tutoring ads lead with the tutor’s own score, and it’s a fair place to start. A tutor who scored 515 or higher has done better than about 9 in 10 test takers, and a 520 puts them around the top 3%. For context, the average MCAT for students who started MD programs in 2025 was 512.1. There’s no official minimum score for tutors, though, and a high score alone doesn’t make someone a good teacher. Use the score to build your shortlist. Then compare how well each tutor explains concepts, how they find where you’re losing points, and whether they’ve helped other students improve.

While it is tempting to select a tutor who received a 528 with minimal studying, always make sure to do your research on how your tutor achieved that score. While some students are naturally adept at standardized test-taking and have near perfect recall, this does not necessarily make that person the best at teaching how to take the test. What worked for a tutor, or for another student, may not necessarily work for you! So let’s keep talking about how to find the tutor that you want to work with.

How Much Tutoring Experience Should My Tutor Have?

Like many things in life, practice makes progress. Good tutors often have strong track records of working with students long-term to achieve their goals. The topic that they tutor is much less relevant than the number of students they have worked with and their success with those students. Many MCAT tutors start out tutoring for the individual subjects covered on the MCAT exam, working with their peers throughout college and honing in on their teaching skills.

When deciding on a tutor, it’s critical to see if they have previous experience teaching STEM topics, and if not, why they think they are qualified to do so. Unless you have a lot of time and are willing to work with a tutor who is also learning themselves, we recommend that you find someone who has experience working with and coaching students to achieve their academic goals.

Does It Matter Where My Tutor Went to College?

This question is a lot easier- it’s a resounding “no”! Since the MCAT is a standardized exam, their performance on the exam should provide you with a lot more information than their undergraduate or post-undergraduate training. Everyone has to learn the same content for the MCAT exam, so there should not be any major differences between the different educational backgrounds of different tutors.

Who Is The Best Tutor for Me?

Do You Prefer Online or In-Person Tutoring?

Online and in-person tutoring can both work well. What matters most is which format you’ll actually show up for consistently. However, different formats work better for different students. While we are strong proponents of online tutoring, studying for the MCAT exam is not a one size-fits-all approach. Your choice of an MCAT tutor may vary based on whether you’d like to set up sessions online, or find someone who is close to your campus for regular sessions.

What Are My Goals for the MCAT?

Start with your own goal score. If you’re aiming for 520+, a tutor who scored in that range knows what the top end of the exam demands. If you’re working toward 505–512, a tutor with a strong score who has helped students make that same jump may fit you better than a 528 who found the test easy. Either way, ask each tutor how they’d get you from your current practice average to your goal.

The same goes with timeline. A tutor who only studied a month for the MCAT, or alternatively, took over 6-months, may suggest a radically different approach than what you’re looking for. Read closely through the description of each tutor you’re considering to see how their study schedule may align with the one you want to use. While many tutors can adapt and work within your parameters, this is something to consider to narrow down who may be the best tutor for you.

Similarly, the resources that a tutor advertises they used or recommend to students can have a large impact on tutoring fit. Some students take extensive courses to study for the MCAT, while others study completely independently. If you already have an idea of how you would like to study, it might be a good idea to select a tutor who has expertise working with those kinds of resources.

Do I Like This Tutor?

The search is not over once you initially connect with a tutor. As a tutor is someone that you will be working with closely to develop a personalized tutoring plan, it’s important that you find someone that you get along with. It’s great if your tutor has a lot of experience and knowledge in the subject area- but that does not matter much if you dread going to your sessions! There’s a lot of flexibility within tutoring, try, try again!

There are a lot of great, and not-so-great, MCAT tutors available for personalized coaching. However, it’s important to take a close look at what different tutors can offer you and how that aligns with your own goals and learning style.

Here’s a list of questions we recommend asking anyone you consider asking to be your MCAT tutor:

  • What score did you receive on the MCAT?
  • How did you study for the MCAT?
  • What lessons did you learn from taking the MCAT?
  • What is your previous tutoring experience?
  • Have you ever tutored for the MCAT?
  • If so, what were your students’ goals and what scores did they ultimately receive?
  • How would you describe your teaching style?
  • What do you do when a student is struggling with a topic?
  • How do you keep your students on schedule?
  • What advice would you give a student that you do not think is going to achieve their goal score within their desired timeline?
  • How will you figure out where I’m losing points?
  • What support do I get between sessions?

Feel free to check out our Tutoring Page on MotivateMD to meet some experienced tutors who would love to start working with you today!

Try a Free MCAT Consultation

  • Free 30-Minute MCAT Consultation

Book a free 30-minute call with a Motivate MD tutor to talk through your weak areas and your study plan. No payment needed.

Book My Free Consultation

What You'll Get:

  • Personalized help on your weak subjects
  • High-yield strategies to ease anxiety and boost your score
  • Completely free—no strings attached!

Written By: Emily L

Published: